Make Good Art - Chip Kidd, Neil Gaiman Four stars for the content itself, I saw the speech previously and it is, of course, awesome. Worth having this around, and thank goodness Gaiman's speech is actually why I bought this, because...

...no damn stars for the awful layout and design of the pages. Some are upside down, others have the print too small, and others are designed so they're extremely difficult to read. I've heard Kidd is excellent on other projects, but this one resembles the creativity of a 12-year-old girl back in the heyday of Geocities and Angelfire webpages (I know because, many many years ago, I was one of those girls). Very disappointing on that score.